The Only Eggnog Recipe You'll Ever Need (2024)

When he's not busy running the co*cktail program at New York City's Maialino, Erik Lombardo is giving Food52 the rundown on all things spirits -- and showing the best ways to drink them.

Today: The holiday drink of all holiday drinks -- minus the preservatives and the long ingredient list, plus the booze.

I thought I hated eggnog. I can clearly remember my eight-year-old self walking down the dairy aisle in the grocery store and being absolutely baffled that anyone would buy that electric yellow, glutinous liquid with a list of ingredients as long as your arm, holiday spirit or no. It didn’t help that I grew up drinking a Puerto Rican version of eggnog made even more delicious with coconut and sweetened condensed milk, but really I like to think I could just spot a phony: According to the FDA, store-bought eggnog can contain as little as 1% egg yolk solids, which in a drink that owes half its name to the egg makes you wonder about the other 99%. Occupy eggnog!

My incredulity disappeared the day I tried my first flip: Rich, creamy, silky, and boozy, this is exactly what eggnog is supposed to taste like. While drinks that use egg white, like classic fizzes and traditional sours, have a light and frothy profile, flips use either the whole egg or the yolk specifically, giving them a rich and silky texture by adding fat to the co*cktail.

In fact, a flip is basically uncooked custard made in a co*cktail shaker. When making custard, eggs and sugar are slowly added to hot milk or cream until thickened. When making a flip, these same ingredients interact, but in the iced environment of a co*cktail shaker. The thickening of a flip is due to the thorough emulsification of the egg.

Like many of the best co*cktails, the origins of the word eggnog are lost to the booze-soaked, addled pages of history, but the two theories thrown around most often attribute it to a contraction of either ‘egg n’ grog’, meaning egg and rum, or to the small wooden cup it was traditionally served in, called a noggin.

You can spike your nog with anything you like -- rum, bourbon, and brandy are the most common. If you use rum, pick out a nice funky Jamaican rum like Smith & Cross. For bourbon use a soft and fruity bourbon like Buffalo Trace. The traditional garnish is nutmeg, though I find adding a bit of cinnamon does no harm at all -- just avoid committing the sin of using pre-ground spices (I understand it’s a hate crime in civilized countries) and have a small spice grater and an actual nutmeg and cinnamon stick handy.

This recipe is for a single glass of eggnog, but feel free to batch it up for a party, though you might want to invest in an immersion blender to give your shaking arm a rest if you’re serving for more than a couple of guests.

2 ounces rum, brandy, bourbon, or a combination

3/4 ounce cream

3/4 ounce simple syrup

1 egg yolk

Photos by James Ransom

This article originally appeared on Food52.com: Eggnog

Food52 is a community for people who love food and cooking. Follow them at Food52.com and on Twitter @Food52. And check out their new kitchen and home shop, Provisions.